Victoria’s gambling industry is on edge as the state government pushes forward with its latest regulatory shake-up: a mandatory carded play system for poker machines. The proposed bill, which would require all gamblers to use a personalised card tracking their spending in real time, has triggered fierce opposition from industry leaders, pub and club owners, and civil liberty advocates.
While officials argue the measure is a necessary step to combat problem gambling and money laundering, critics warn it could devastate businesses, alienate patrons, and push more gamblers toward unregulated or online alternatives. Many see the bill as yet another example of the government’s heavy-handed approach to gambling regulation—one that threatens the industry’s survival under the weight of ever-increasing restrictions.
Regulatory Overreach or Necessary Reform?
Victoria’s gambling sector has been hit with a wave of tough regulations in recent years, many introduced in response to high-profile scandals at Crown Resorts and Star Entertainment. While the government insists these measures are essential for accountability, industry voices argue they are becoming overbearing, creating an environment that feels more punitive than protective.
As a result, gambling experts point to the popularity of international markets and professional resources as more enthusiasts access Card Player reviews for news and expert recommendations on sites that locals can play on. These reviews highlight online betting platforms and bookmakers that attract players with great benefits such as cashback, rewards, and better odds than available on traditional platforms.
Businesses are struggling, and this could be the final blow. The carded play proposal represents the most sweeping change yet. The system would force every poker machine user to register for a government-linked gambling card, logging every dollar spent in the name of consumer protection. While proponents claim this will help track problem gamblers and identify potential money laundering, critics argue it’s an invasive, costly, and ineffective solution.
The Business Backlash
Latest Stories
For pubs, clubs, and smaller operators, the economic ramifications of mandatory carded play are a major concern. Many venues rely on poker machines to stay afloat, and opponents argue the bill could drive regular gamblers away—either to unregulated markets or entirely out of the system.
Trade groups have been particularly vocal about the financial burden of implementing such a system. Upgrading machines, training staff, and maintaining compliance would add significant costs, potentially forcing smaller venues out of business.
This is a sledgehammer approach to a problem that needs a scalpel, according to some pub associations. Others feel like the government is treating every gambler like a criminal, and that’s going to drive them away. They feel that people won’t just stop gambling—they’ll just go where there are fewer rules.
With many venues still recovering from the financial strain of the pandemic, industry representatives warn that an additional regulatory hurdle could spell disaster. They believe if this bill passes, jobs will be lost, businesses will close, and entire communities will suffer. The government doesn’t seem to understand how crucial these venues are to local economies.
An Unrealistic Benchmark?
Supporters of the bill often point to Crown Resorts, which has successfully rolled out a carded play system at its Melbourne casino. However, critics argue that using Crown as a model ignores key differences between large corporate operators and smaller, independently run venues.
The Crown can afford this—most pubs and clubs can’t. The financial and logistical burden of implementing this across Victoria’s thousands of gaming venues is immense. It’s comparing apples to oranges. Smaller operators, they argue, don’t have the deep pockets or resources to integrate complex tracking technology without suffering significant losses.
A Broader Trend of Increasing Regulation
Victoria’s proposed gambling reforms are part of a national trend toward stricter regulations in the industry. From advertising bans to poker machine limits, Australian states have been ramping up oversight in recent years.
While many of these reforms are framed as harm reduction measures, critics argue they often create more problems than they solve. New South Wales’ recent attempt to reduce poker machine numbers—only to abandon the plan due to cost and ineffectiveness—is a prime example of what happens when regulation outpaces practicality.
The Road Ahead
As Victoria’s Parliament prepares to debate the mandatory carded play bill, the stakes are high. While the government positions the measure as a necessary reform, industry leaders, pub owners, and gaming advocates warn it could have devastating unintended consequences.
Beyond the immediate concerns for businesses and jobs, the bill also raises larger questions about the future of gambling regulation in Australia. How far is too far? And at what point does protecting consumers turn into excessive control? For now, all eyes are on Victoria. The outcome of this debate could set the tone for gambling regulations across the country. One thing is clear: if the bill passes, the industry is in for a fight.
